Season 1, Episode 19 : Neptune's Spatula

While at the Fry Cook Museum, SpongeBob pulls a legendary spatula out of a bucket of grease. The legend states "whoever pulls the spatula out will be Neptune's servant". Neptune and SpongeBob enter a cooking contest to see who can make 1,000 Krabby Patties first. Neptune wins, but SpongeBob's patty was made with love so his is better than all of Neptune's. SpongeBob wins but instead of being Neptune's cook, he teaches Neptune to make a Krabby Patty by love, not magic.